House sends Hegseth impeachment articles to committee, 211-204, as 11 Democrats miss the vote
Republicans used a procedural motion to sideline Rep. Thomas Massie's impeachment articles against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, and Democrats now say they may revive the effort when they take the majority in January.
The House voted 211-204 on Tuesday to refer Rep. Thomas Massie's resolution to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to the Judiciary Committee. The move effectively shelves the eight articles for the rest of this Congress. Massie, a Kentucky Republican, was the only Republican to vote against the motion, and no Democrats voted for it. He accused Hegseth mainly over the U.S. war with Iran and over alleged abuses of his office.
Eleven Democrats and seven Republicans did not vote. The Democratic absences exceeded the seven-vote margin, and a tally cited by The Washington Sun shows the motion would have failed 215-211 had all 11 voted no. Several of the Democrats blamed a traffic incident and a police-escorted bus near the Capitol. Others cited a medical or personal matter or an event, or gave no reason. The episode drew criticism from some Democratic colleagues.
Hegseth called the effort a "farce" and a "political spectacle," and President Trump said it "miserably FAILED!" House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries said afterward that it was "just the beginning." Democrats take control of the House in January after last week's midterms, and some Democrats have said they expect to pursue impeachment then. Others, including Rep. Pete Aguilar, have stressed oversight first.
Massie told Fox News Digital that Democrats may reuse some of his articles and add others, possibly on Ukraine military aid. He said he could not substantiate the Ukraine allegations himself. Impeachment needs a simple House majority, while conviction needs two-thirds of the Senate.
Cited facts
The House voted 211-204 to refer Massie's impeachment resolution against Hegseth to committee, which effectively kills it for the remainder of this Congress.
Eleven Democrats and seven Republicans did not vote.
The referral went to the Judiciary Committee.
Several absent Democrats, including Reps. Stansbury, Gillen, Jackson and Strickland, said a traffic incident and a police-escorted bus or motorcade delayed them. Some said they have since recorded their intended 'no' votes.
Absent Democrats also gave other explanations: a medical procedure for Rep. Correa, a veterans event for Pelosi, and an unspecified denial of the ability to vote for Rep. Pettersen.
Hegseth called the impeachment effort a 'farce' and 'political spectacle', and Trump said it 'miserably FAILED!'
✓ 1CBS NewsDemocrats are set to take over the House in January after last week's midterm elections, and the vote may therefore not be the last on Hegseth.
Impeachment requires a simple House majority, while conviction and removal require a two-thirds Senate majority.
✓ 1Fox News
Where reports differ
Democrats' traffic explanation is the members' own account. ABC reported it had not heard back from Capitol Police about the traffic incident, and that Reps. Brownley, Horsford, Stevens and Wilson had not explained their absences. ABC also noted members knew of the scheduled vote at least 18 hours earlier.
Common Dreams reported that some absent Democrats had attended an event hosted by what it called an 'AIPAC front group'. It did not say which members. MS NOW reported that Rep. Crockett, who was not among the absent members, said she was at the same event. Common Dreams said the traffic-citing lawmakers had not answered whether they were returning from it.
A senior Democratic aide, cited by The Washington Sun, disputed that traffic-blocked members would have changed the outcome. The aide said Republicans had only two members unavailable and closed the vote while others were en route. CNN and CBS reported seven Republicans did not vote.
Democratic signals on timing differ. Aguilar, in line to be majority whip, played down a rush to impeach Hegseth again and stressed oversight first. Rep. Pettersen said she expects Democrats to vote to impeach him in January.
Fox News reported that some Democrats left open further articles over Hegseth's handling of Ukraine military aid, citing Massie and Rep. Grijalva. Massie said he could not substantiate allegations that aid was improperly withheld. Only Fox and outlets repeating its report covered this angle.
Heritage Foundation legal fellow Zach Smith, quoted by Fox, said Democrats' impeachment push is an 'unfortunate waste of time' and aims to discourage conservatives from serving in future Republican administrations. This is one commentator's claim and appeared only in Fox's coverage.
Perspectives: how each side framed it
See how left, center, right and international outlets framed this story, and which claims only some of them reported.
Unlock with Plus · $4.99/moChecked outlets
12 outlets · 3 left · 6 center · 1 right · 2 international. Each opens the outlet's own article.
- CNN (Left)Read it at cnn.com (opens CNN)
- Common Dreams (Left)Read it at commondreams.org (opens Common Dreams)
- MS NOW (Left)Read it at ms.now (opens MS NOW)
- ABC News (Center)Read it at abcnews.com (opens ABC News)
- CBS News (Center)Read it at cbsnews.com (opens CBS News)
- Scripps News (Center)Read it at scrippsnews.com (opens Scripps News)
- Spectrum News (Center)Read it at spectrumlocalnews.com (opens Spectrum News)
- The Hill (Center)Read it at thehill.com (opens The Hill)
- The Washington Sun (Center)Read it at washingtonsun.com (opens The Washington Sun)
- Fox News (Right)Read it at foxnews.com (opens Fox News)
- Al Jazeera (Intl)Read it at aljazeera.com (opens Al Jazeera)
- CBC News (Intl)Read it at cbc.ca (opens CBC News)