Nvidia Hires Outside Law Firm to Investigate CEO Jensen Huang's Admitted Relationship With Alleged Chinese Intelligence Asset
Nvidia's board has retained a former federal prosecutor to lead its probe of CEO Jensen Huang, whose stock has fallen and who now faces a shareholder suit and demands from Congress.
Nvidia's board said Tuesday it has retained the law firm Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz to run its independent investigation of CEO Jensen Huang. The firm's Joon Kim, a former acting U.S. attorney for the Southern District of New York, will lead it. The board announced the probe Sunday after reports that Huang was the target of a foreign intelligence effort. The board has said it has no reason to believe national security or company secrets were compromised.
Huang has admitted to an extramarital relationship with Alice Huang, a former executive at the Singapore-based cloud company Megaspeed International. The New York Times reported that U.S. intelligence concluded she was gathering information for Beijing. China's foreign ministry has called the claim groundless and a smear. President Trump said Monday that the FBI is looking into the matter and that Huang told him he did not know she was a spy.
Nvidia shares fell more than 4% Monday and about 6% Tuesday, as investors weighed whether the scandal could force Huang out. A shareholder lawsuit filed by the Rosen Law Firm now alleges Nvidia and Huang misled investors about the affair and the company's ties to Megaspeed. Huang held closed-door meetings at the Santa Clara headquarters Tuesday, a day after apologizing to senior executives, according to reports.
In Washington, Republican senators pressed for answers about who in the administration knew of the suspected operation and how Chinese buyers of Nvidia's advanced chips were vetted. Investigators are also reportedly examining how restricted chips may have reached China. Megaspeed denies wrongdoing, and none of the spying allegations has been proven.
Cited facts
Nvidia's independent directors retained Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz, with former acting U.S. attorney Joon Kim, to conduct the investigation, as announced Tuesday.
The board first announced the independent investigation on Sunday, Nov. 8, after reports that Huang was the target of a foreign intelligence effort. A committee of independent directors oversees it with outside counsel.
The board said it has no reason to believe that national security or Nvidia secrets were compromised, and that its inquiry would examine all available information.
The New York Times reported that U.S. intelligence determined Alice Huang, a former Megaspeed executive, was gathering information for Beijing.
China's foreign ministry has rejected the spy allegation as a smear.
Trump said Huang told him on Monday that he did not know she was a spy, and said the FBI is looking into the matter.
A securities suit from the Rosen Law Firm alleges Nvidia and Huang made false or misleading statements about the affair and Nvidia's relationship with Megaspeed.
Megaspeed bought more than $4.8 billion of Nvidia chips over two years, according to The Times. The Commerce Department had been investigating whether Megaspeed helped China sidestep export rules, and Nvidia said its compliance team found nothing illegal.
Megaspeed denies wrongdoing and says inspections found no violations.
✓ 1CNBCHuang held closed-door meetings at Nvidia's Santa Clara headquarters on Tuesday after apologizing to senior executives on Monday.
Senate Republicans pressed Tuesday for answers on who in the Trump administration knew of the suspected operation, whether the FBI should have warned Huang, and how Chinese firms cleared to handle Nvidia chips were vetted.
Where reports differ
Only The Week reports that short seller Culper Research found up to 40% of Nvidia's data-center business was linked to China through Southeast Asian intermediaries. Yahoo Finance reports only that the firm raised China-exposure concerns months earlier.
That Huang did not know Alice Huang was a spy is Huang's position as relayed by Trump. It has not been independently verified. The spy allegation itself rests on U.S. intelligence assessments reported by the NYT, and China denies it.
Outlook India, citing Reuters, says the FBI is separately examining whether Huang was himself targeted. Trump described the FBI inquiry only as looking into 'something else'. The FBI declined to comment, according to an aggregator site.
A single aggregator site, citing a CNBC report and a House committee statement, says House Foreign Affairs leaders asked Huang to brief Congress on Nov. 18 and to respond by Nov. 11, with a subpoena possible. Its account also says Singapore police investigations into Megaspeed are ongoing. Neither point was confirmed in the other outlets read.
Only the Washington Examiner's article carries Sen. John Kennedy's reaction.
Perspectives: how each side framed it
See how left, center, right and international outlets framed this story, and which claims only some of them reported.
Unlock with Plus · $4.99/moChecked outlets
9 outlets · 5 center · 1 right · 3 international. Each opens the outlet's own article.
- Bloomberg (Center)Read it at bloomberg.com (opens Bloomberg)
- CBS News (Center)Read it at cbsnews.com (opens CBS News)
- CNBC (Center)Read it at cnbc.com (opens CNBC)
- CNBC (Center)Read it at cnbc.com (opens CNBC)
- CNBC (Center)Read it at cnbc.com (opens CNBC)
- PBS NewsHour (AP) (Center)Read it at pbs.org (opens PBS NewsHour (AP))
- Yahoo Finance (Center)Read it at finance.yahoo.com (opens Yahoo Finance)
- Washington Examiner (Right)Read it at washingtonexaminer.com (opens Washington Examiner)
- Outlook India (Intl)Read it at outlookindia.com (opens Outlook India)
- Streamline Feed (Kenya) (Intl)Read it at streamlinefeed.co.ke (opens Streamline Feed (Kenya))
- The Week (India) (Intl)Read it at theweek.in (opens The Week (India))