Local · Ada County, Idaho · Friday, November 6, 2026

SHARED WITH YOU

Idaho Supreme Court orders partial release of body camera video from fatal shooting of Deputy Tobin Bolter

The state's high court ruled that parts of the video must be released under public records law, while a segment showing the moments after the shooting may be withheld for family privacy.

The Idaho Supreme Court ruled on Monday, November 2, that parts of body-camera video from the April 2024 shooting of Ada County Sheriff's Deputy Tobin Bolter must be released under public records law. The justices unanimously found that the recording is a public record because Bolter was on duty when it was made.

The case started with a public records request from Garth Gaylord, filed about six months after the shooting. A district court had ordered the full video released, but Sheriff Matt Clifford appealed. The high court divided the roughly 13-minute recording into sections and concluded that a segment running from 00:38 to 08:35 can be withheld to protect the Bolter family's privacy, since it shows the deputy's last moments and first responders' aid.

Sheriff Clifford said his office respects the decision and will comply with it, while stating that footage of the final moments and the lifesaving efforts should remain protected. Reports differ on how much of the video the release will cover, and the court's ruling did not specify a release date in the coverage reviewed.

Cited facts

  1. The Idaho Supreme Court ruled that portions of the body-camera footage from the fatal shooting of Deputy Tobin Bolter must be disclosed under a public records request.

  2. The court unanimously held that the recording is a public record because Bolter was on duty when it was made.

  3. The court found that releasing a segment from 00:38 to 08:35 would be an unwarranted invasion of the Bolter family's personal privacy.

  4. The records request was filed by Garth Gaylord about six months after the April 20, 2024 shooting.

  5. Sheriff Matt Clifford said his office respects the ruling and will comply with it.

  6. The footage remains a public record even after the officer who recorded it is incapacitated, according to the court.

Where reports differ

Boise State Public Radio's lead describes the release as covering the initial seconds of the footage, while the court's text withholds only the 00:38 to 08:35 segment, which suggests other parts beyond that window are to be produced.

Perspectives: how each side framed it

PLUSPRO

See how left, center, right and international outlets framed this story, and which claims only some of them reported.

Unlock with Plus · $4.99/mo

Checked outlets

4 outlets · 4 center. Each opens the outlet's own article.

Something look off? Tell us

Baseline checks the day's top stories across the spectrum

Every morning: the facts outlets on the left, center and right agree on, with every one linked to its source.

The Baseline newsletter

The morning's facts in your inbox: the top national and global stories, with cited facts. Free on every plan. Signing up also creates your free Baseline account.