Democrat leads in Ada County Commission District 1 race; incumbent Beck holds District 2
Unofficial results show Democrat Kelceymarie Warner ahead of Republican incumbent Ryan Davidson by 400 votes as Ada County turnout rose sharply.
Unofficial results from the November 3 election show Democrat Kelceymarie Warner ahead of Republican incumbent Ryan Davidson in the Ada County Commission District 1 race, by 400 votes out of more than 218,000 cast for the seat. Once all 197 precincts had reported, the margin was about 0.18 percentage points. If the result holds, Warner would be the first Democrat on the three-member commission in years. In District 2, Republican incumbent Rod Beck kept his seat against Democrat Michael Fitzgerald by 594 votes.
Turnout was high. Reports put Ada County turnout at roughly three-quarters of registered voters, which is above the 2022 midterm level but below 2018. County Clerk Trent Tripple said more people voted than in recent midterm elections. Ada County also voted against the statewide trend in the Senate race, where Independent Todd Achilles beat Republican Jim Risch by about three points within the county, according to the Idaho Statesman.
Davidson called the loss disappointing and congratulated Warner, and he attributed the outcome to a national trend, higher turnout on Proposition 1, and the off-year ballot. Warner said voters seemed to want less partisan candidates and that she would first explore a moratorium on data center applications. Proposition 1 failed statewide but passed in Ada County, according to the Statesman.
Cited facts
Warner had 109,704 votes (50.09%) to Davidson's 109,304 (49.91%), a 400-vote gap, after all 197 precincts reported in unofficial results.
Beck retained the District 2 seat with about 50.14% of the vote, beating Democrat Michael Fitzgerald by 594 votes.
Warner is described as the first Democrat on the Ada County Commission in years; the last was Kendra Kenyon, who did not seek a second term in 2022.
Ada County turnout was about 75% of registered voters, and the preliminary count was 74.6%, with 232,003 ballots cast out of 311,099 registered voters.
Ada County's turnout exceeded the 61.4% recorded in the 2022 midterms but fell short of the 78.2% recorded in 2018, according to county data.
✓ 1BoiseDevAchilles beat Risch by about three points in Ada County, and the county had backed the Republican candidate in every U.S. Senate race back to at least 1994, per Secretary of State data.
Where reports differ
Turnout figures vary by timing: the Statesman reports about 75%, while BoiseDev's preliminary count was 74.6%. An earlier BoiseDev count on November 4 showed 69.2%.
Davidson attributed his loss to the national 'blue wave', Proposition 1 turnout, and the off-year election, according to the Statesman. Warner said it was not clear what made the difference, but that ballot questions such as Proposition 1 drove turnout.
Warner said her first priority would be to explore a moratorium on data center applications. This is a stated campaign intention reported by KIVI; no county action on it was reported in the coverage reviewed.
Perspectives: how each side framed it
See how left, center, right and international outlets framed this story, and which claims only some of them reported.
Unlock with Plus · $4.99/moChecked outlets
5 outlets · 5 center. Each opens the outlet's own article.
- BoiseDev (Center)Read it at boisedev.com (opens BoiseDev)
- Idaho Press (Center)Read it at idahopress.com (opens Idaho Press)
- Idaho Statesman (via Yahoo News) (Center)Read it at yahoo.com (opens Idaho Statesman (via Yahoo News))
- KIVI (Idaho News 6) (Center)Read it at kivitv.com (opens KIVI (Idaho News 6))
- Yahoo News (Center)Read it at yahoo.com (opens Yahoo News)