Russian bombing of aid distribution site in Komyshuvakha, Zaporizhzhia region, kills at least 53, Ukrainian officials say
Ukrainian officials say a Russian guided-bomb attack on a former school used as an aid point and shelter on Nov. 2 has killed at least 53 people, with dozens still believed missing as searches continue.
Russian guided bombs hit a former school in the village of Komyshuvakha, in Ukraine's Zaporizhzhia region, on Monday, Nov. 2. The building served as a shelter and as a weekly aid distribution point. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said classes there had long been suspended because of the village's closeness to the front.
Zelenskyy said the first bombs struck as people arrived to collect aid. Further bombs, which he put at nine, then hit the shelter where people had taken cover. Ukrainian emergency services said two rescue workers and four police officers were among the dead. The toll rose from the mid-20s on the day of the attack to 40 by Nov. 4 and 43 by Nov. 5. On Nov. 6, acting regional governor Mykhailo Semikin put it at 53.
Search-and-rescue work was in its fifth day on Friday. Officials say several dozen people may still be missing or trapped, and Russian drones and the threat of repeat strikes have complicated the work. The strike came a day after a six-day, U.S.-brokered local ceasefire for civilian evacuations in the Russian-occupied town of Oleshky expired. It also came shortly before planned U.S.-hosted talks in Abu Dhabi between Ukrainian and Russian delegations.
Reuters reported that Russia's Defence Ministry said it had targeted Ukrainian military units around Komyshuvakha and two other settlements, and that up to 25 Ukrainian servicemen were killed. Reuters also noted that both Russia and Ukraine deny deliberately targeting civilians. A UN human rights monitoring official said local authorities had publicly announced the distribution beforehand, and that the attack appeared to violate humanitarian law.
Cited facts
A Russian guided-bomb attack on Monday, Nov. 2 hit a former school in Komyshuvakha, Zaporizhzhia region. The building was used as a shelter and handed out humanitarian aid every Monday.
Acting regional governor Mykhailo Semikin said on Nov. 6 that the death toll had reached 53, as search and rescue work entered its fifth day.
Zelenskyy said the first bombs hit people arriving for aid, and that a follow-up strike with nine more bombs hit the shelter where people were taking cover.
At least two rescue workers who went to help after the first strike were among those killed.
Dozens of people were still reported missing or possibly trapped under rubble. On Nov. 4 Zelenskyy said more than 30 may be trapped, and Zaporizhzhia official Ivan Fedorov said 59 were missing.
The strike came a day after a six-day, U.S.-brokered local ceasefire in the Russian-occupied town of Oleshky expired.
The attack came shortly before planned three-way talks in Abu Dhabi between Ukraine, Russia and the United States.
Zelenskyy said the world's reaction had been very limited and called for more air defense support for Ukraine.
Russia and Ukraine both deny deliberately targeting civilians.
Where reports differ
Russia's claim: Reuters reported that Russia's Defence Ministry said it hit Ukrainian military units near Komyshuvakha and two other settlements, killing up to 25 servicemen. No independent verification of this claim appeared in the reports I read. Anadolu, reporting on Nov. 4, said Russian authorities had not commented on the attack.
Number of bombs: Zelenskyy, Kyiv Independent and CNN describe a first strike followed by nine more bombs on the shelter. AP says ten guided bombs destroyed the facility, and Kyiv Independent reports Ukrainian officials identified a 3-ton FAB-3000 among the munitions.
Missing count: Fedorov cited 59 missing on Nov. 4, while Zelenskyy said more than 30 may be trapped under rubble. Ukrainian outlets later reported that seven people previously listed as missing were found alive; I read that only in search excerpts from Ukrainian outlets, not in the wire reports.
Toll figures varied by source and date. On Nov. 5 Reuters cited police at 42, while Zelenskyy gave 43. On Nov. 6 the Emergency Service had said 50 before the governor said 53.
Composition of the dead: emergency services, as reported by NBC (carrying Reuters text), said two rescue workers and four police officers were among the dead. Kyiv Independent's Nov. 6 report mentions two rescue workers and a military medic.
Distance from the front: Reuters gives about 17 km (11 miles) to the nearest Russian positions, while Kyiv Independent says about 20 km from the front line.
Perspectives: how each side framed it
See how left, center, right and international outlets framed this story, and which claims only some of them reported.
Unlock with Plus · $4.99/moChecked outlets
9 outlets · 2 left · 2 center · 1 right · 4 international. Each opens the outlet's own article.
- CNN (Left)Read it at cnn.com (opens CNN)
- NBC News (Left)Read it at nbcnews.com (opens NBC News)
- AP (via WRAL) (Center)Read it at wral.com (opens AP (via WRAL))
- Reuters (via AOL) (Center)Read it at aol.com (opens Reuters (via AOL))
- Newsmax (Right)Read it at newsmax.com (opens Newsmax)
- A News (Türkiye) (Intl)Read it at anews.com.tr (opens A News (Türkiye))
- Al Jazeera (Intl)Read it at aljazeera.com (opens Al Jazeera)
- Anadolu Agency (Intl)Read it at aa.com.tr (opens Anadolu Agency)
- Kyiv Independent (Intl)Read it at kyivindependent.com (opens Kyiv Independent)