NTSB probes Learjet 60 crash in Palm Beach County that killed nine; tail part found miles away
Investigators say the Nov. 1 Learjet 60 began breaking apart before it hit the ground, but the cause of the crash has not been determined.
A privately operated Learjet 60 crashed in a residential area of Palm Beach County, Florida, around 12:50 p.m. on Nov. 1. It had left Austin, Texas, for North Eleuthera in the Bahamas. All nine people aboard, two crew and seven passengers, were killed.
At a news conference Tuesday, NTSB member Tom Chapman said most of the jet's left elevator, a tail surface that controls pitch, was found in three pieces. They were between 1.3 and 3.8 miles from the crash site. Investigators say this confirms the plane was coming apart before impact. Chapman said it is not yet known whether losing the elevator caused the loss of control or whether forces on the aircraft tore it off. He also said the part may not have been effective at the speeds involved even if it had stayed attached.
Air traffic control audio shows the crew reported ice and turbulence, then declared an emergency. They reported an overspeed condition and a descent rate of about 20,000 feet per minute. Thunderstorms were in the area, and weather is a focus of the investigation. Investigators have not said what role it played. They are examining the pilots, the aircraft and the operating environment, and they have received dashcam video. They are also working in a water-filled crater at the impact site.
The crash blocked the only entrance to a mobile home park, and hundreds of residents were displaced. Relatives have identified the dead, who include a Texas technology entrepreneur, his wife and their two young children, along with the two pilots. An NTSB preliminary report is expected in about a month. Determining the probable cause will likely take more than a year.
Cited facts
A Learjet 60 that left Austin-Bergstrom for North Eleuthera, Bahamas, crashed in Palm Beach County, Florida, around 12:50 p.m. on Nov. 1, killing all nine aboard.
The nine people aboard were two crew members and seven passengers.
✓ 1ABC NewsNTSB member Tom Chapman said most of the left elevator, the tail surface that controls pitch, was found in three pieces between 1.3 and 3.8 miles from the crash site.
Investigators say the aircraft was breaking apart before it hit the ground.
The NTSB has not determined whether losing the left elevator contributed to the crash or whether it was torn off by forces on the plane as it fell.
Chapman said the elevator may not have been effective at those speeds even if still attached, but that its loss is important evidence pointing to other things to investigate.
✓ 1Global NewsThe NTSB says its investigations examine three areas: the pilot, the aircraft and the operating environment.
✓ 1CNNA water-filled crater at the impact site complicated the search for wreckage. Investigators planned to access it Wednesday.
Victims include technology entrepreneur Adam Robinson, his wife Helen Sharp and their two young children. Pilot Jeff Gregory, 55, was also killed.
An NTSB preliminary report is expected in about a month, and determining the probable cause will likely take more than a year.
The crash is the second-deadliest in the U.S. this year and the deadliest involving a Learjet 60, according to CNN's citing of NTSB records and Flight Safety Foundation data.
✓ 1CNN
Where reports differ
Number of people displaced differs. AP/Global News reported about 600 nearby residents displaced, Bloomberg (via Insurance Journal) said about 400, and ABC cited the evacuation of hundreds of people from 77 mobile homes.
Descent-rate figures come from different data. The pilot told controllers the plane was descending at about 20,000 feet per minute, and ADS-B data showed a maximum rate above 32,000 feet per minute, as AVweb reported. CNN reported a drop of more than 27,000 feet in one minute.
Interpretations of the tail-piece finding differ. A former NTSB investigator told Fox News that the pilots' effort to level the jet may have over-stressed the structure and torn the part off. An expert told AP the pieces were probably a result of the nosedive, not the cause. The NTSB has not said which is right.
The co-pilot's stepfather told the New York Post, as relayed by AP, that she texted her boyfriend about 10 minutes before the crash about turbulence and ice. This is a family account reported by one outlet and is not verified by investigators.
Fox News carried a related headline saying the NTSB found 'no evidence' of a Mar-a-Lago connection to the crash. The other outlets I read did not address this, and I did not read the underlying report.
Early reports said no one on the ground was confirmed injured. Later reports said one man in a vehicle near the site had a leg injury.
Perspectives: how each side framed it
See how left, center, right and international outlets framed this story, and which claims only some of them reported.
Unlock with Plus · $4.99/moChecked outlets
7 outlets · 1 left · 4 center · 1 right · 1 international. Each opens the outlet's own article.
- CNN (Left)Read it at cnn.com (opens CNN)
- ABC News (Center)Read it at abcnews.com (opens ABC News)
- AP (as carried by NBC News) (Center)Read it at nbcnews.com (opens AP (as carried by NBC News))
- AVweb (Center)Read it at avweb.com (opens AVweb)
- Insurance Journal (Bloomberg report) (Center)Read it at insurancejournal.com (opens Insurance Journal (Bloomberg report))
- Fox News (Right)Read it at foxnews.com (opens Fox News)
- Global News (Intl)Read it at globalnews.ca (opens Global News)