Spain's transport minister resigns six days after Urda high-speed train crash that killed 69
Óscar Puente quit on Nov. 3 after the second deadly high-speed rail collision in Spain this year, and the prime minister named Economy Minister Carlos Cuerpo to run the ministry on an interim basis.
Spain's Transport Minister Óscar Puente announced his resignation on Tuesday, Nov. 3. He made the announcement at the end of a long appearance before a standing committee of lawmakers. The committee sits while parliament is dissolved ahead of the Nov. 29 election. He did so six days after two high-speed trains collided near Urda, in Toledo province, killing 69 people. Puente said a transport minister could not stay in office after two accidents of this gravity in under a year. He also said he would not stand as a candidate in the election.
In the Oct. 28 crash, a signalling system failed on the Madrid-Seville line and several trains were automatically stopped. Central controllers in Madrid then authorised a Renfe train, run by the state, to proceed even though a train run by the private operator Iryo was stationary ahead. The Renfe train hit it. Investigators are focusing on the failure of the LZB train-control system and on the instructions the controllers gave. In January, a separate crash on the same line near Adamuz killed 46 people.
Puente had repeatedly refused to resign in the days after the crash, and opposition parties had demanded he go. On Tuesday he said he had decided to quit within minutes of learning of the crash but stayed on until emergency and safety measures were in motion. Earlier that day he announced fewer trains on the Madrid-Seville line until the European train-control system (ERTMS) is rolled out. He also announced changes to control-centre procedures and a 30-million-euro aid package for victims.
Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez praised Puente. On Wednesday he said Carlos Cuerpo, who is also economy minister, would provisionally run the Transport Ministry. The People's Party's leader, Alberto Núñez Feijóo, answered Sánchez's praise by saying the prime minister should step aside too. The party's parliamentary spokesperson said the resignation came too late. Far-right Vox was sharply critical of Puente.
Cited facts
Puente announced his resignation on Tuesday, Nov. 3, at the end of a lengthy appearance before lawmakers about the crash.
The Oct. 28 collision near Urda, in Toledo province, killed 69 people.
A signalling failure on the Madrid-Seville line preceded the crash. Central controllers in Madrid then authorised a Renfe train to proceed even though an Iryo train was stationary ahead, according to Puente.
It was the second deadly high-speed rail crash in Spain this year. A January crash near Adamuz, on the same Madrid-Seville line, killed 46 people.
Puente said a transport minister in Spain cannot remain in office after two accidents of such severity in less than a year.
Puente said he decided to resign immediately after the crash but did not make it public until later.
Puente also said he would not stand in the Nov. 29 early parliamentary election.
Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez called the Nov. 29 election, and Puente's departure comes less than four weeks before it.
Before resigning, Puente announced safety measures: fewer trains on the Madrid-Seville line until ERTMS is in place, a faster ERTMS rollout, and improvements to control centres.
Opposition parties had called for Puente to resign, and he had earlier ruled it out.
Sánchez praised Puente on X after the announcement.
On Nov. 4, Sánchez said Economy Minister Carlos Cuerpo would provisionally run the Transport Ministry.
The investigation into the Urda crash is focusing mainly on the failure of the LZB train-control system and possible errors in instructions from the Adif control centre.
The government announced a 30-million-euro aid package for Urda victims.
Where reports differ
Injury counts differ. The Telegraph says some 50 people were injured, while Euronews says around 200. Other outlets say only 'dozens' or do not give a figure.
The crash site is described as about 130 km south of Madrid by dpa and about 150 km south by Latin Times.
Latin Times says the Madrid-Seville line remains shut pending judicial authorisation, with service possibly resuming within ten days. Reuters and dpa describe Puente's measure as a reduction in services. Only Latin Times reports a closure.
Only Euronews and Latin Times say the train was allowed to continue at over 160 km/h after the LZB system failed. The Telegraph says only that a controller told the driver to proceed at full speed.
Puente's account that he decided to quit right after the crash is his own claim. Reuters adds that he told only his family and not Sánchez. The Telegraph and dpa report that he and Sánchez had repeatedly ruled out a resignation in recent days.
Latin Times quotes Sánchez as saying Puente stepped aside out of respect for the victims and 'the progressive project'. Reuters instead describes Sánchez praising his political dignity and responsibility.
The People's Party spokesperson said the resignation came '116 deaths late', which is the party's own tally. Other outlets give a combined toll of 115 (69 plus 46).
Only Reuters reports that the resignation takes effect once it is published in the official state gazette.
Vox's criticism is reported in different terms. Euronews says it accused Puente of shirking responsibility. The Telegraph says it called him a 'minister of death' and the government a 'criminal gang'. These are party claims, not established facts.
Perspectives: how each side framed it
See how left, center, right and international outlets framed this story, and which claims only some of them reported.
Unlock with Plus · $4.99/moChecked outlets
10 outlets · 4 center · 1 right · 5 international. Each opens the outlet's own article.
- AP via PBS News (Center)Read it at pbs.org (opens AP via PBS News)
- Latin Times (Center)Read it at latintimes.com (opens Latin Times)
- Reuters via The Spokesman-Review (Center)Read it at spokesman.com (opens Reuters via The Spokesman-Review)
- Reuters via ThePrint (Center)Read it at theprint.in (opens Reuters via ThePrint)
- Breitbart (Right)Read it at breitbart.com (opens Breitbart)
- ABC News (Australia) (Intl)Read it at abc.net.au (opens ABC News (Australia))
- Al Jazeera (Intl)Read it at aljazeera.com (opens Al Jazeera)
- dpa via Yahoo News (Intl)Read it at yahoo.com (opens dpa via Yahoo News)
- Euronews (Intl)Read it at euronews.com (opens Euronews)
- The Telegraph via Yahoo News (Intl)Read it at yahoo.com (opens The Telegraph via Yahoo News)